Amazon vs Shopify vs Etsy at a Glance
Amazon is a retail marketplace, Etsy is a marketplace for handmade and creative goods, and Shopify is a platform for building your own store. That difference affects every fee, visitor, and customer relationship.
| Dimension | Amazon | Shopify | Etsy |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Retail marketplace | Your own storefront platform | Handmade, vintage, and craft marketplace |
| Built-in buyers | Hundreds of millions of shoppers | None; you drive traffic | 90M+ active buyers with gift intent |
| Upfront cost | $39.99/mo Pro or $0.99 per sale | Basic plan around $39/mo | $0.20 per listing; no required monthly fee |
| Brand control | Low | High | Medium |
| Customer data | Restricted | Yours | Restricted |
- Choose Amazon for established products, strong margins, and the largest base of purchase-ready shoppers.
- Choose Shopify to build a durable brand and own your customer data, if you can invest in marketing.
- Choose Etsy for handmade, vintage, craft, or digital products and low-risk access to niche buyers.
Marketplace or Storefront: The Difference That Decides Everything
Amazon and Etsy are marketplaces: you rent shelf space where shoppers already browse. Shopify gives you a store, but no one walks past unless you bring visitors there.
- Marketplaces provide distribution on day one; storefronts provide a website and a traffic to-do list.
- Marketplaces charge per sale because they deliver customers; storefronts charge a subscription because you deliver customers.
- Marketplace customers belong to the platform. A Shopify buyer relationship, email list, and repeat-purchase potential belong to you.
- Marketplaces set the rules and design. Your own store is yours to shape.
Neither model is universally better. A handmade maker may earn more on Etsy than on a Shopify store with no visitors, while a repeat-purchase consumer brand will eventually need its own storefront.
Fee Comparison: What Each Platform Actually Takes
Compare the full stack, not only the headline percentage: listing costs, transaction fees, processing, fulfillment, advertising, and the price of acquiring traffic.
Amazon
Amazon charges a referral fee, roughly 15% for most categories, plus a Professional plan at $39.99/month or $0.99 per item on the Individual plan. FBA, storage, and Sponsored Products add more. Referral fees and fulfillment often consume 25–40% of the sale before product costs.
Shopify
Basic Shopify costs about $39/month, with card processing near 2.9% + $0.30 per online transaction using Shopify Payments. Apps, domain, themes, and marketing add to the real cost. The subscription buys no visitors.
Etsy
Etsy charges $0.20 per listing, a 6.5% transaction fee, and payment processing around 3% + $0.25 per order in the US. A $30 order is roughly 11% before optional or required Offsite Ads.
The fee question to ask: What does one order cost after fees, ads, and acquisition? A lower percentage is not cheaper if you must pay heavily to find every customer. Verify current prices in the Amazon fee schedule and Etsy fee policy.
Traffic and Discovery: Who Brings the Buyers?
Amazon gives you search demand. Buyers arrive ready to shop, but ranking depends on sales velocity, conversion, reviews, pricing, and often advertising.
Etsy gives you niche intent. Buyers look for gifts, personalization, and products with a story. Titles, tags, listing quality, and service affect discovery.
Shopify gives you tools, not traffic. You earn visits through SEO, content, social, email, and ads. The upside is that the audience you build is yours.
Ask whether you already have an audience and can afford to build one. For search tactics, see our Amazon A9 Algorithm Guide and Etsy SEO Tips.
Brand, Control, and Customer Data
Amazon and Etsy customers are customers of the marketplace. Your brand appears inside a shared shopping environment, buyer contact is restricted, and policy or account changes can put revenue at risk.
Shopify gives you control of the domain, checkout, content, email capture, segments, loyalty programs, and remarketing. That ownership takes more work, but compounds as your brand grows.
Which Platform Fits Which Seller?
Handmade makers and artists → Etsy. Etsy has built-in demand for jewelry, ceramics, art, and personalized goods. Add Amazon Handmade or Shopify as you scale.
Vintage sellers → Etsy. Vintage is a core category with built-in demand, while Amazon restricts used-item selling and Shopify requires you to find buyers.
Private-label and consumer brands → Shopify first, Amazon second. Build brand equity and capture email on Shopify, then add Amazon when margins support fees, fulfillment, and ads.
Dropshippers and import sellers → Shopify. Shopify has the strongest app ecosystem; Amazon has strict dropshipping rules and Etsy prohibits reselling mass-produced goods you did not design or make.
Digital creators → Etsy or Shopify. Etsy offers discovery for printables and templates; Shopify is stronger for higher-value digital products, software, or subscriptions.
How to Choose: A 5-Step Framework
- 1Confirm the platform allows your product and category.
- 2Price a real order through each fee stack, including fulfillment and marketing.
- 3Decide where your buyers already are and whether you can build an audience.
- 4Decide how much brand ownership and customer data matter in three years.
- 5Start with one channel, prove the math for 60 days, then add a second deliberately.
Best Practices After You Pick a Platform
- Lead with clear, consistent, well-lit product images that show scale and use.
- Write search-aware copy with real shopper language, benefits, and specifications.
- Price with fees, shipping, returns, and customer acquisition built in.
- Collect reviews honestly and within each platform’s rules.
- Capture customer data wherever the platform allows it, especially on Shopify.
- Review unit economics monthly: fees, ads, returns, and true cost per order.
ImageChat turns product photos into polished, platform-ready descriptions and captions. Use the Product Description Generator to keep copy consistent across channels.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for beginners: Amazon, Shopify, or Etsy?
For beginners with a product that fits, marketplaces are usually faster: Etsy for handmade or creative goods and Amazon for standard consumer products. Shopify is better if you already have an audience or can invest in building traffic.
Is Etsy only for handmade items?
Etsy also allows vintage items at least 20 years old, craft supplies, and digital downloads. Mass-produced resale is not allowed unless you design and produce the items with an approved production partner.
Can I sell the same products on all three platforms?
Yes. Many sellers use Amazon or Etsy for discovery and volume, plus Shopify as their brand home. Optimize each listing for its platform and price for each fee structure.
Which platform has the lowest fees?
For a typical $30 sale, Etsy is roughly 11% in listing, transaction, and processing fees, while Amazon is around 15% in referral fees before fulfillment. Shopify has lower per-sale processing fees, but marketing and customer acquisition can make its true cost higher.
Is Shopify good for handmade sellers?
Yes, when you want a branded store, customer data, and higher long-term control. Handmade sellers with no audience often get faster first sales on Etsy, so running both can be a strong path.
Does Shopify get you customers?
No. Shopify provides the store, checkout, and tools, but no marketplace audience. You earn visits through SEO, content, social media, email, or paid ads.
Should I sell on Amazon or start a Shopify store?
Use the margin and audience test. Amazon can scale proven products quickly, while Shopify builds brand equity and customer ownership. For many brands, Amazon or Etsy works as acquisition and Shopify as the owned home base.
Create Better Listings for Every Channel
Turn one product image into platform-ready copy for Amazon, Shopify, and Etsy.
Start Generating Product Descriptions